Courtyard vs Phygitals
We may earn a commission from links on this page. How we earn money
Courtyard wins overall, 9.9 to 9.6. Courtyard is stronger on pull value, buyback & fees, shipping & support and promos; Phygitals is stronger on transparency.
Side by side
| Metric | Courtyard | Phygitals |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 9.9 (better) | 9.6 |
| Pull value | 9.0/10 (better) | 8.5/10 |
| Buyback & fees | 9.5/10 (better) | 8.0/10 |
| Transparency | 7.5/10 | 8.5/10 (better) |
| Shipping & support | 8.0/10 (better) | 7.0/10 |
| Promos | 7.0/10 (better) | 6.0/10 |
| Buyback | 90% (better) | 85% |
| Buyback window | Instant | 30 minutes to 7 days |
| Cheapest pack | $25 | $25 |
| Price range | $25-$10,000 | $25-$250 |
| Welcome offer | Guaranteed $25+ buyback on the $25 starter pack | - |
| US shipping | FedEx at cost from the vault; vaulting and insurance free | Paid by user on redemption |
| Payments | Apple Pay · Bank transfer · Card · Crypto · Google Pay | Apple Pay · Card · Crypto · Google Pay |
| Vault | Brink's | PSA, Fanatics, Alt |
| Blockchain | Polygon | Solana |
| Provably fair | No | Yes |
| Minimum age | 18+ | 18+ |
| Restricted states | None listed | None listed |
Read our Courtyard review · Read our Phygitals review
Courtyard and Phygitals both sell digital packs backed by vaulted cards that are tokenized on a blockchain. The main difference: Courtyard offers instant buyback, a fee-free marketplace and shipping priced before checkout. Phygitals offers draws you can verify yourself, more card games, and bank payouts, but with a short buyback window on standard cards and unpublished shipping costs.
Which has the better buyback?
Compare the headline rates in the side-by-side table above. Beyond the rate:
- Courtyard offers buyback on fair market value, priced with Card Ladder data, instantly after the reveal. Its terms call it a best-effort offer that is limited in duration.
- Phygitals offers a standard rate on fair market value, with boosted rates on some packs. Standard cards have a window measured in minutes, while sealed-product and inventory cards get several days.
Our buyback rates comparison shows how both stack up against the other sites.
Which is more transparent about draws?
Phygitals. Its draws are provably fair: a committed server seed plus your client seed, which you can verify yourself. Neither site publishes per-card odds, and we did not find a provably fair scheme at Courtyard. Learn how to check a provably fair rip before you rely on it.
Which covers more categories?
For cards, Phygitals. It lists One Piece, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Riftbound and Dragon Ball alongside Pokémon and sports, and we could not confirm those games at Courtyard. Beyond cards, Courtyard adds luxury watches and rare coins, Phygitals adds figurines and wine and spirits, and both list comics. One Piece collectors can see the full field in our best One Piece rip sites ranking.
How do fees, cash-outs and shipping compare?
| Cost or option | Courtyard | Phygitals |
|---|---|---|
| Vault | Brink’s, tokenized on Polygon | PSA, Fanatics and Alt, tokenized on Solana |
| Marketplace | 0% buyer and seller fees | On-chain marketplace, plus cross-listing on Fanatics Collect |
| Cash-out | USDC only, no fee listed for digital transfers | Bank transfer, or USDC, USDT or SOL with network fees paid by Phygitals |
| Shipping | FedEx at cost, shown before checkout | You pay shipping, handling, taxes and duties; amount not published |
Which has the stronger track record?
Courtyard has more behind it. It raised a $30M Series A led by Forerunner in July 2025 and has a much larger base of Trustpilot reviews. Phygitals is reportedly bootstrapped, its Trustpilot profile is unclaimed with only a handful of reviews, and FinanceFeeds reports $250M in total volume. The trust signals on each review have the current ratings.
Which should you choose?
- Pick Courtyard if you want instant buyback, shipping prices before checkout and a fee-free marketplace.
- Pick Phygitals if you want draws you can verify, or you collect One Piece, Yu-Gi-Oh! or Riftbound.
- Pick Phygitals if you want to cash out to a bank account rather than in USDC.
Pack opening involves chance at both sites, so set a budget before you start.